Monday 11 March 2019

Cheltenham Festival 2019 - Day One

SKY BET SUPREME NOVICES' HURDLE
2 Miles 87 Yards, Grade 1 Novice Hurdle


Overview
Last year’s Willie Mullins hotpot, Getabird, was not fancied on the trends with just the 2 hurdles runs under his belt before the festival. The last 10 winners now have 4 or 5 starts over the sticks before winning this. With the issues of good winter ground and the Equine Influenza problem, we may find this won’t be the case this year. Allowances could be made for those with 3 runs, who perhaps have been off the track a little longer. However it may also strengthen the trends and those who weren’t inconvenienced, coming to the fore.


Last 10 Winners- average 4.5 stars
2018  *****  Summerville Boy (9/1)
2017  **        Labaik (25/1)
2016  *****  Altior (4/1)
2015  *****  Douvan (2/1 fav)
2014  *****  Vautour (7/2 jt fav)
2013  *****  Champagne Fever (5/1)
2012  *****  Cinders And Ashes (10/1)
2011  ****    Al Ferof (10/1)
2010  ****    Menorah (12/1)
2009  *****  Go Native (12/1)


10-year Trends
10/10 Had won over 2 miles.
10/10 Had run between 4 and 5 times over hurdles.
10/10 Were aged 5 or 6. [1 placed horse from 21 runners outside of this age group]
  9/10 Had run less than 11 times in total in their career. [Labaik had 15, but refused to start in 6 of the last 8, flat and jumps]
  9/10 Had an Adjusted Racing Post Rating (A.RPR) of at least 150. The last 9 had an Official Rating (OR) of 142+.
  9/10 Had run within the last 67 days. [Exceptions 80 and 115 days]
  9/10 Were not flat-bred horses.
  8/10 Had won at least 50% of their hurdles. [Exceptions the last 2 years]
  8/10 Had won last time out (LTO). [Menorah, 2nd in 2010 and Labaik (RR), but won his last 'race']
  8/10 Were rated within 10lbs of the Top A.RPR.
  8/10 Had won a Grade 1 or Grade 2 Hurdle. 7 of the last 8 winners had achieved this. [Menorah winning a Class 2 Hurdle and Labaik a Grade 3, and refused in 2 Grade 1&2 races]


Additionally
Only one 4-year old has won in the last 44 years.[Hors La Loi III in 1999]
40 of the last 44 winners were aged 5 or 6.
22 of the last 24 winners had run within the last 68 days. 18 of those, within the last 45 days.
19 of the last 22 winners had won last time.
13 of the last 15 winners had run in 4 or more hurdles races.
Flown (blinkered) in 1992, was the last horse to win with headgear. 35 horses beaten. He’s also the last horse to win after just one hurdle run.


Ages (Win-Place-Runs)
4yo 0-0-2
5yo 4-14-80
6yo 6-5-61
7yo 0-1-13
8yo 0-0-5
9yo 0-0-1


Trainers (Win-Place-Runs)
Willie Mullins (Ire)  3-3-27
Nicky Henderson  1-8-18
Gordon Elliott (Ire)  1-1-4
Tom George 1-0-2
Paul Nicholls 1-0-5


Contenders
***** Al Dancer (9/2)
Fine winner of the Grade 3 Betfair Hurdle. The stats say that as he’s yet to win a Grade 1 or 2 and he comes from a handicap that he can’t win. Plenty of Betfair Hurdle winner come close though and he comes here highly rated.

****   Angels Breath (9/2)
Won the Supreme Trial on debut and his 2nd in the Dovecote Hurdle probably enhanced his chance here, however with just 2 runs over hurdles coupled with that defeat last time I’ll pass. I also want my horses in this ground to have won over at least the trip and he’s only won over 1m71/2f

***     Aramon (16/1)
Beaten a head by Klassical Dream last time, but is a Grade 1 winner. He’s an ex-flat horse with plenty of miles on the clock. Doesn’t fit the winners profile.

*         
Beaufort West (200/1)
Out of his depth here.

*         
Brandon Castle (25/1)
Won his last 3 races, but all at a lower level. Unlikely to feature.

***** Elixir De NutzNON RUNNER

***** Felix Desjy (25/1)
Won a Grade 2 last time back down to 2 miles. Was running, unsuccessfully over 2 and a half. Lively outsider.

***     Grand Sancy (12/1)
Behind Elixir De Nutz and Itchy Feet this season, but won the Grade 2 Kingwell last time in Open Company. He’s a second season Novice with 11 hurdle runs and has to be overlooked,

**       
Itchy Feet (33/1)
Missed his prep with the Influenza outbreak and therefore is a little behind on the trends. Beaten by Elixir De Nutz last time he was seen in November, but no surprise if he out ran these odds.

***     Klassical Dream (4/1 fav)
Flat-bred who didn’t win that much in France, now he’s won a Grade 1, but with 7 runs to his name. Rated fairly low by the Racing Post but has to be respected.

****   Mister Fisher (14/1)
Seriously considered, but does only have 3 runs. He’s just a tick off the 150 APR too. Only won over the bare 2 miles too.

*         
Normal Norman (200/1)
3rd in the Dovecote Hurdle, miles behind Angels Breath.

**       
The Big Bite (33/1)
Behind Mister Fisher and Thomas Darby in December and hasn’t been seen since. Not good enough

*         The Flying Sofa (200/1)
Yet to win so far and is ignored.

***     Thomas Darby (25/1)
Not rated high enough to win and yet to race in Graded company. Beaten by Mister Fisher 2 runs ago.

**       
Tokay Dokey (100/1)
Fell early on in the Dovecote, so we’ll never know. Was 14/1 that day, so unfancied and has to be passed over.

*         
Vision D’honneur (11/1)
6 lengths behind Klassical Dream and Aramon last time. Not rated high enough and shouldn’t be turning that form around here.

***** Fakir D’oudairies (11/2)
While 4 year olds don’t have a great record in the race, many are no-hopers. This one ticks all the other boxes and with the 8lbs allowance for 4yos, becomes top-rated.


Conclusion
Some decent horses in this without it looking a classic. Brandon Castle is the lone pace angle now with Elixir De Nutz absent. The Racing Post doesn’t seem to rate the Irish form, while the official handicapper does. The trends seem to fall with the British horses. Every horse seems to have a reason not to back them. With the rain that is forecast to come on Tuesday, I definitely want to be with a horse who has winning form over more than the bare 2 miles, whether Felix Desijy’s stamina over much further will help or hinder is anyone’s guess, though his Grade 1 success was on Good ground. Al Dancer has done nothing wrong and should be up and around. Fakir d’oudairies may be avoiding Sir Erec in the Triumph Hurdle (same ownership) but is worth serious consideration.

Selection
All bets will assume the rain has come in the morning and the ground will be soft.
Money has come for the Irish horses. Great stuff.

FAKIR D’OUDAIRIES @ 13/2, Paddypower, 6/1 general
Best horse on ratings.

FELIX DESJY @ 28/1 e/w, Paddypower, Unibet, 25/1 general
Grade 1 winner with proven stamina. 28/1 is far too big.




RACING POST ARKLE CHALLENGE TROPHY
NOVICES' CHASE
1 Mile 7 Furlongs 199 Yards, Grade 1 Novice Chase


Overview
No superstar hurdler this year and cases can be made for quite a few. Chase experience is key and Graded Chase experience an obvious advantage.


Last 10 Winners- average 4.7 stars
2018  *****  Footpad (5/6 fav)
2017  *****  Altior (1/4 fav)
2016  *****  Douvan (1/4 fav)
2015  *****  Un De Sceaux (4/6 fav)
2014  **        Western Warhorse (33/1)
2013  *****  Simonsig (8/15 fav)
2012  *****  Sprinter Sacre (8/15 fav)
2011  *****  Captain Chris (6/1)
2010  *****  Sizing Europe (6/1)
2009  *****  Forpadydeplasterer (8/1)


10-year Trends
10/10 Top 2 in all Chase finishes.
10/10 Had run within the last 80 days.
10/10 Were not flat-bred.
  9/10 Aged 6 or 7 years old. [Sizing Europe won aged 8 in 2010.]
  9/10 Had an Adjusted RPR of 160 or more. (OR 152+) [Exception: Western Warhorse (148), had only 1 run]
  9/10 Rated within 6lbs of the RPR Top Rated. [Exception: Western Warhorse (23lbs) in 2014]
  9/10 Ran to a Hurdles rating of 143 or more. [Exception: Western Warhorse 130. 8 of last 9 rated 151+.]
  9/10 Had won last time. [The last 9 winners]
  9/10 Won a Novice Chase between 2m and 2m3f. Exception won at 2m41/2f.
  8/10 Had 3/4 Chase starts. Both exceptions less.
  8/10 Had a course win or had a top 4 finish at a previous festival.


Additionally
30 of the last 32 winners had finished 1st or 2nd on their last start.
26 of the last 28 winners started at 9/1 or less.
19 of the last 21 winners had not unseated/fallen in their chase career.
18 of the last 20 winners were aged 5-7.
17 of the last 19 winners had a hurdles rating of 142+,


Ages (Wins-Places-Runners)
  5yo 0-0-4
  6yo 4-3-28
  7yo 5-10-42
  8yo 1-3-12
  9yo 0-0-6
10yo 0-0-1


Trainers (Wins-Places-Runners)
Willie Mullins (Ire)  3-1-10
Henry de Bromhead (Ire)  1-2-7
Colin Tizzard 0-1-1
Tom George 0-1-3


Contenders
**       Articulum (25/1)
Aged 9, and shouldn’t be good enough on what he’s done so far with just the 2 starts.

**       Clondaw Castle (25/1)
Winning at a lower level, more needed here.

****   Duc Des Genievres (6/1)
Hasn’t done too much, but ticks a lot of the boxes. His form is over 21/2m and they’ll surely be too quick for him here.

****   Glen Forsa (4/1 fav)
Put Kalashnikov in his place last time and has won all 3 starts, including the Grade 2 Kingmaker last time. This usually goes to a classy hurdler, and he certainly wasn’t one of those.

***     Hardline (5/1)
Beaten 6 lengths into 3rd last time and has now had 6 starts. He’s all the rage in Ireland and has halved in price in the week. If it turns up soft, his stamina will kick in here.

***** Kalashnikov (8/1)
Form has taken a knock in the last 2 races, but he does tick a lot of boxes. A nice bit of rain will help.

***     Knocknanuss (20/1)
Fell last time, has been running over 21/2m as well and rain wont really help him. Also had 5 runs over fences and is a 9yo.

***     Lalor (11/2)
Just 2 runs over fences and well beaten last time at Sandown 3 months ago. Definitely good enough, but needs to bounce back and bust a few trends.

**       Ornua (14/1)
Highly rated, but doesn’t tick as many boxes as he should. He’s 8 with 7 chase runs so far and has been off for 3 months and didn’t win last time. Wouldn’t be surprised if he ran well though.

***     Paloma Blue (11/1)
Only the 2 starts so far and beaten 13 lengths on debut. Can’t be having him here.

**       Slate House (66/1)
Beaten 128 lengths in his 3 starts so far. Much, much more required here.

**       Us And Them (14/1)
Runner-up to Le Richebourg and Hardline this season. Hard to fancy.


Conclusion
Kalashnikov is the trends horse, will like some rain too and ran really well in the Supreme last year. But has made telling mistakes in his last 2 defeats. Everyone else has their own problems as well, including Lalor and Hardline. Both beaten into 3rd last time, but both Graded Chase winners. Glen Forsa probably the correct favourite.


Selection
Just because of his assured stamina, HARDLINE is the pick. Kalashnikov is too shot now although he may well run well.

HARDLINE (11/2) Ladbrokes/Coral




ULTIMA HANDICAP CHASE
3m 1f, Grade 3 Handicap Chase


Overview
Fancied horses are coming to the fore in recent years, although I can’t quite pick the one. Coo Star Sivola became the first 6 year old to win since 1994.


Last 10 Winners- average 3.8 stars

2018  ****    Coo Star Sivola (5/1 fav)
2017  ***      Un Temps Pour Tout (9/1)
2016  ****    Un Temps Pour Tout (11/1)
2015  ***      The Druids Nephew (8/1)
2014  ****    Holywell (10/1)
2013  ***      Golden Chieftain (28/1)
2012  ***      Alfie Sherrin (14/1)
2011  *****  Bensalem (5/1)
2010  *****  Chief Dan George (33/1)
2009  ****    Wichita Lineman (5/1 fav)


10-year Trends
10/10 Won over 2 miles 71/2 furlongs or more.
  9/10 Aged between 6 and 9 years old. 7 were aged 7 or 8.
  9/10 OR no bigger than 148. [Previous winner Un Temps Pour Tout was rated 148 & 155]
  9/10 Had run between 2 and 5 times that season. [Golden Chieftain racked up 7 before winning this]
  9/10 Had achieved a Chase RPR of 143. [Alfie Sherrin was the worst rated winner (135)]
  9/10 Had run within the last 47 days. [The last 9 winners][Wichita Lineman was off for 94 days]
  8/10 Finished in the top 3 in one of the last 2 starts. 2 winners were unplaced in decent Hurdle races last time.
  8 /10 Had run less than 10 times over fences. [None more than 14 starts.]
  7/10 Carried no more than 11-03 in weight. [All 3 within the last 5 years].


Additionally
The last 13 winners had between 2 & 7 runs that season.
19 of the last 20 winners were aged between 7 and 10.
17 of the last 19 winners had won over 3 miles or more
Only two horses aged 11 or more have placed since 1997.


Ages (Wins-Places-Runners)
  6yo 1-3-16
  7yo 2-10-41
  8yo 5-5-59
  9yo 1-7-53
10yo 1-2-28
11yo 0-2-16
12yo 0-0-4
13yo 0-0-1


Trainers (Wins-Places-Runners)
Jonjo O'Neill 3-1-14
Nick Williams 1-2-3
Neil Mulholland 1-1-7
Colin Tizzard 1-0-10
Nicky Henderson 0-3-13
Lucinda Russell 0-1-2
Gordon Elliott (Ire) 0-1-2
Tom George 0-1-4
Sue Smith 0-1-6
Paul Nicholls 0-1-11

Contenders
**       Lake View Lad (20/1)
9 year old, off since Boxing Day, this top-weight is in good form, and I won’t put you off baking him as he’ll love the ground.

*         Sizing Codalco (100/1)
Exposed 10 year old is far too high in the weights to win this.

**       O O Seven (66/1)
10th in this last year, runs off the same mark, so similar result expected.

**       Minella Rocco (8/1)
Placed in the Gold Cup a couple of years ago, but beaten too often nowadays.

*         Activial (40/1)
Doesn’t look a 3 miler to me and has had a busier season than most winners. Opposed.

*         Mister Whitaker (7/1)
Won the Close Brothers Handicap last year. Up in trip in this is a risk. I like my horses to be proven in these competitive handicaps.

**       Beware The Bear (14/1)
4th last year, up 1lb from that. Stays on well but make too many mistakes and off since New Years Day a negative, but loves the ground and has place chances.

**       Magic Of Light (20/1)
Won a Grade 2 Hurdle in January, and is in good form, a little high in the weights trendswise, and with 13 Chase starts, a little to experienced, but 2 starts here is too harsh. Shortlisted.

**       Royal Vacation (25/1)
Consistent sort, a little too high in the weights for me but can’t rule out completely. But I really want to oppose 9 year olds if I can.

*         Noble Endeavor (14/1)
Elliott/Russell combinations must be respected, but he’s 10 now and is carrying too much weight.

****   Crucial Role (20/1)
Would have had a perfect weight for this if he hadn’t won 2 weeks ago. Now he’s slightly too high in the weights. Very strange. Ticks all the other boxes too and was probably a bet.

***     Calipto (16/1)
Had a busy year, can’t fully rule out, but ground may have gone against him now.

***     Singlefarmpayment (16/1)
Well backed in 2 renewals of this, 2nd then 5th last year. Felt his chance has passed now.

****   Up For Review (7/1)
He’s 10 now, and has run poorly in both starts at the course.
****   Give Me A Copper (6/1 fav)
Just 1 run in 16 months, difficult to recommend and great that he’s taking a chunk out of the market. His 3 mile win was a 2 runner affair, so hardly awe inspiring stuff.

****   Coo Star Sivola (9/1)
Winner last year on Heavy ground, up 3lbs on that this time around, Not the same good preperation this year, off for 88 days a negative and he hasn’t fired at all this season, beaten 109 lengths.

***     Vintage Clouds (25/1)
Had wind surgery and has been off since pulling up in the Welsh National. Was 3rd last year, but needs to step up again. Will like the mud and stays all day. Place chance at best though.

***     General Principle (20/1)
10 year old marathon stayer. Not really a Cheltenham horse and is opposed.

***** Willie Boy (50/1)
Needs to improve his jumping, fell on both trips to the course. But only 5 star horse in field.

**       Flying Angel (66/1)
Never won as far as this and think he’s more of a speed horse. Track doesn’t appear to suit him either.

*         Shantou Village (100/1)
Off since November and out of form. Hard to see him featuring.

****   Oldgrangewood (100/1)
Another out of form and surely better over shorter.

****   Catamaran De Seuil (33/1)
Couldn’t have jumped any worse last time at Kempton. Should be better over shorter too.

***     Big River (25/1)
Stays and likes the softer ground. But out of form and been off since December.


Conclusion
Irish Trainers have a bad record in the race, having not won it since 2006. Shortlisted Magic Of Light IS trained by Jessica Harrington. A Chance is taken on Crucial Role. Maybe Dan Skelton knows how much he’s got in hand and just wanted him in the race when winning last time. Honourable mentions for Beware The Bear and Lake View Lad for placepot purposes

Selection
CRUCIAL ROLE e/w (22/1, Ladbrokes/Coral)
MAGIC OF LIGHT e/w (22/1, Paddypower, 20/1 general)




UNIBET CHAMPION HURDLE CHALLENGE TROPHY
2 Miles 87 Yards, Grade 1 Hurdle


Overview
Buveur D’Air aims to become the 7th horse to win 3 Champion Hurdles, however this looks a lot stronger renewal than his previous wins. Apple’s Jade looks a serious contender and Laurina is on the upgrade and looks quality too.
.

Last 10 Winners- average 3.8 stars
2018  *****  Buveur D'Air (4/6 fav)
2017  ***      Buveur D'Air (5/1)
2016  ****    Annie Power (5/2 fav)
2015  ****    Faugheen (4/5 fav)
2014  ****    Jezki (9/1)
2013  ***      Hurricane Fly (13/8 fav)
2012  **        Rock On Ruby (11/1)
2011  *****  Hurricane Fly (11/4 fav)
2010  *****  Binocular (9/1)
2009  ****    Punjabi (22/1)


10-year Trends
10/10 Had won at the distance. [The last 9 over an extended 2 miles.]
10/10 Were rated within 8lbs of the RP Top Rated horse.
  9/10 Had an Adjusted RPR of 168 or more. [OR 162+]. [Buveur D'Air (163) had started the 2016/17 season as a Novice Chaser]
  9/10 Had between 5 and 12 Hurdle runs. [Hurricane Fly (19) was a previous winner.]
  9/10 Had won a Grade 1 Hurdle. [Rock On Ruby, just at Listed level]
  8/10 Had won a Class 1 Hurdle that season, 6 won a Grade 1, 1 a Grade 2 and 2 won a Listed race. [Annie Power had just 1 prep run before winning]
  9/10 Were aged between 6 and 8 years old. [Hurricane Fly (9) was a previous winner. No horse aged 10 or more has won since Sea Pigeon in 1980 & 1981.]
  8/10 Had run within the last 51 days. All ran within 79 days.
  7/10 Had won last time out. Exceptions were, 2nd, 3rd and 4th in Graded Hurdles.


Additionally
27 of the last 29 winners had won that season.
29 of the last 35 winners had won last time.
24 of the last 28 winners were from the first 5 in the betting.
23 of the last 27 winners had placed at a previous festival.
21 of the last 31 winners had won at Cheltenham.
The only 5-year-old to win since 1985 was Katchit in 2008.
Since 1951, only 4 winners were 9 or older. Only 2 winners were aged 10+
No reigning Supreme Novice Winner has won since 1971.
Since 1993, only 2 winners had not run in that calendar year.


Ages (Wins-Places-Runners)
  5yo  0-4-28
  6yo  4-7-30
  7yo  4-2-23
  8yo  1-4-17
  9yo  1-1-7
10yo  0-1-4
11yo  0-1-4
12yo  0-0-2
13yo  0-0-1


Trainers (Wins-Places-Runners)
Nicky Henderson  4-6-23
Willie Mullins (Ire)  4-5-19
Gordon Elliott (Ire) 0-1-1


Contenders
**       Brain Power (33/1)
Ran in this 2 years ago, won a Grade 2 last time but hasn’t got the required rating for this.

***** Buveur D’Air (11/4)
The reigning duel-champion. Beaten by Verdana Blue this season. Should go close.

*         Espoir D’Allen (16/1)
Probably comes a year too early for this 5 year old.

**       Global Citizen (66/1)
4th behind Verdana Blue and Buveur D’Air at Christmas, so much more to find here.

**       Melon (16/1)
Beaten a length by Buveur D’Air last year, not in the same form this season.

***** Sharjah (16/1)
Ryanair Hurdle winner at Christmas, off the track since, but ticks all the boxes. Not sure connections thought he’d be good enough as he was running in the Galway Plate in the summer.

*         Silver Streak (100/1)
Beaten by Global Citizen and Brain Power this season, this looks far too hot for him.

****   Apple’s Jade (15/8 fav)
Beaten in the Mares’ Hurdle last year, but was found to be in season after. She also went there after a break when she needs a run beforehand. She has that now, but her front running style may set up the race for something else.

***** Laurina (7/2)
Not beaten anything, however her 6 victories have been by 106 lengths. Perfect on the trends and her if they go off too fast in front, may set up the race for her and her proven stamina.

**       Verdana Blue (25/1)
Wouldn’t want any rain, but beat Buveur D’Air at Christmas, ran on the All-Weather as a prep run, which is bad news for Grade 1 horses at the Festival.

Conclusion
Apple’s Jade likes to lead out, but maybe taken on by Global Citizen. Paul Kealy is the Racing Post doesn’t think he will lead, thus giving Apple’s Jade a chance to lead them out. She’ll take a lot of pegging back if that’s the case. Laurina hasn’t beaten anything, so far. She is perfect on the trends and we are also forgetting the Champion. It’s a race where I don’t want to particluarly commit myself. One of the top 3 will win. Sharjah looks best of the rest.

Selection
Whatever you want. Laurina is perfect on the trends though. Buveur D’Air’s drift may also make him a bet tomorrow. 11/4 also too big.




OLBG MARES’ HURDLE
(REGISTERED AS THE DAVID NICHOLSON MARES’ HURDLE)
2 Miles 3 Furlongs, 200 Yards, Grade 1 Hurdle


Overview
The Willie Mullins benefit continued last season, with 2 potential stars going for the Champion Hurdle, this looks a pretty weak renewal.


La
st 10 Winners- average 4.8 stars
2018  *****  Benie Des Dieux (9/2)
2017  ****    Apple’s Jade (7/2)
2016  *****  Vroum Vroum Mag (4/6 fav)
2015  *****  Glens Melody (6/1)
2014  *****  Quevega (8/11 fav)
2013  *****  Quevega (8/11 fav)
2012  *****  Quevega (4/7 fav)
2011  *****  Quevega (5/6 fav)
2010  ****    Quevega (6/4 fav)
2009  *****  Quevega (2/1 fav)


10-year Trends
10/10 Aged between 5 and 7 years old or were a previous winner. [Quevega won as a 8,9 & 10 year old]
10/10 Raced between 4 and 17 times over Hurdles. [4-10 hurdles with Quevega and a lucky Glenn’s Melody had more]
10/10 Rated within 14lbs of RP Top Rated. [5lbs looks more like it with 8 in that area]
10/10 Won over 2m4f or more.
10/10 Had an Adjusted RPR of at least 156. [OR 147+]
  9/10 Had won a race worth £22k.
  8/10 Won last time. [Exceptions were 9th in a Grade 2 and 2nd in a Grade 1]


Ages (Wins-Places-Runners)
  4yo  0-0-2
  5yo  2-1-22
  6yo  1-8-50
  7yo  4-4-44
  8yo  1-6-35
  9yo  1-0-8
10yo  1-0-3
11yo  0-0-1


Trainers (Wins-Places-Runners)
Willie Mullins (Ire) 9-3-16
Gordon Elliott (Ire) 1-1-3
Alan King 0-2-7
Harry Fry 0-1-4
Jessica Harrington (Ire) 0-1-7

.
Main Contenders
**       Alletrix (100/1)
Doesn’t look up to the required standard.

***** Benie Des Dieux (5/6 fav)
Ticks all the boxes and does win off a break. The one to beat.

*         Cap Soleil (33/1)
2nd in the Mares’ Novice last year, off the track since, so not the worst 33/1 in the world. Has won off a break.

*         Champagne Lady (100/1)
3rd in the Mares’ Novice last year, off the track since. Yet to win past 2 miles. Big ask.

*         Elimay (20/1)
Beaten by Good Thyne Tara last time on first run for Willie Mullins, step up in trip may suit.

**       Good Thyne Tara (40/1)
Beat Elimay before being well beaten by Laurina at Punchestown. A 9yo now and is overlooked.

**       Jester Jet (33/1)
Another 9yo, who’s run 22 times over sticks. Not for me today.

*         Lackaneen Leader (100/1)
Behind a few of these last time and not good enough.

***     Lady Buttons (14/1)
Plenty of racing in her and ultra consistent on all grounds and trips, over fences and hurdles. Place chances.

**       Limini (9/1)
3rd in this 2 years ago. She’s now 8 and isn’t getting any better.

***     Mia’s Storm (28/1)
Now 9, she’s also pretty consistent, she’s mainly been seen over 3 miles, so that has to be a worry.

*         Momella (20/1)
A fall and pulled-up in the last 2 races. Hard to recommend

***     Roksana (15/2)
3rd in Open company behind Buveur D’Air last time. That was over 2 miles, so stepping back up will be in her favour.

*         Slowmotion (66/1)
Been running over all sorts of trips and not winning. And she won’t be winning here.

*         Stormy Ireland (9/1)
Beaten by 2 Champion Hurdle contenders in the last 2 races, so 1 star is terribly harsh, but she hasn’t won past 2m 2f and on softer ground that’s a worry.

Conclusion
Its hard to find anything to beat Benie Des Dieux. Literally, nothing stands out, even in the without market.

Selection
No bet at the moment.




CLOSE BROTHERS NOVICES’ HANDICAP CHASE
2 Miles 4 Furlongs, 78 Yards, Listed Novice Chase


Overview
Usually the tightest handicap of the meeting, the top band was raised to 145 (from 140) last year. Since the introduction of the JLT, the handicap was hugely compressed. It’s basically not a handicap.


Last 10 Winners- average 4.2 stars
2018  *****  Mister Whitaker (13/2)
2017  ***      Tully East (8/1)
2016  ****    Ballyalton (12/1)
2015  ****    Irish Cavalier (11/1)
2014  *****  Present View (8/1)
2013  ****    Rajdhani Express (16/1)
2012  ***      Hunt Ball (13/2 fav)
2011  *****  Divers (10/1)
2010  *****  Copper Bleu (12/1)
2009  ****    Chapoturgeon (8/1)


10-year Trends
10/10 Had won at least a Class 3 Chase or Hurdle.
10/10 Had last run within the last 45 days.
  9/10 Had finished in the top 3 last time they completed.
  9/10 Had raced over fences between 3 and 5 times. [Hunt Ball (9)]
  9/10 Hadn't won more than 2 chases. [Exception Hunt Ball won 6 as he went 50lbs up the ratings.]
  8/10 Had not run in a Graded Chase so far. [Exceptions fell in a Grade 2 and 2nd of 3 in a Grade 3, 6th in a Grade 1.]
  7/10 Aged 6 or 7. Horses aged 6 or 7. All 7 in the last 8 years. [Others were 5, 8 & 9]
  7/10 Had won over at least 2m 4f. [Exceptions won over 2m1 (twice) and 2m2]


Additionally
Only 1 horse that carried a penalty ran into a place.
Since the start, 6 and 7 year olds have won 11 renewals from 160 runners, all other ages are 3 from 114.
Horses in first time head-gear have placed 6 times in the last 10 renewals. (No such horses ran last year.)


Ages (Wins-Places-Runners)
  5yo 1-1-12
  6yo 4-7-43
  7yo 3-11-75
  8yo 1-7-49
  9yo 1-4-17
10yo 0-0-2


Trainers (Wins-Places-Runners)
Nicky Henderson 1-4-18
Paul Nicholls 1-1-8
Philip Hobbs 1-1-10
Gary Moore 0-1-2
Colin Tizzard 0-1-6


Contenders
***     Highway One O One (12/1)
Had 6 chases and yet to win over this far. Consistent but has only run in small fields, A good 2nd on Trials day behind Kildisart gives him a chance.

**       Red Indian (20/1)
Only won a Class 4 Chase, so plenty of improvement needed.

**       Cubomania (11/1)
11 Chases and 4 wins in his career, so would be an unusual winner of this, but has been well backed recently.

****   A Plus Tard (6/1 fav)
Got a chance, his 2nd in a Grade 3 last time has to be respected, even if its a negative in this race. I don’t like that trend particularly. French form is on bad ground.

***** Lough Derg Spirit (20/1)
Perfect on trends, 25 length beating by Glen Forsa won’t seem so bad if that one wins the Arkle. Won’t want the ground to go too soft.

***     Ben Dundee (22/1)
Little form to go on since his last win in November. Questions to answer especially on soft ground.

***** Tower Bridge (8/1)
Former Grade 1 winning Hurdler, but not won over fences so far. Not a problem in this of course.

***     Militarian (66/1)
9 year old with 3 wins in 10 runs. All negatives in this.

***     Walt (20/1)
Won over 3 miles last time. He’s a 2nd Season Novice and prefers better ground. Difficult to recommend here.

****   The Russian Doyen (22/1)
Struggles over this far, flattering 4 star.

***     Springtown Lake (12/1)
75 days off the track and disappointing then. Will like the softer ground though.

***** Roaring Bull (20/1)
Has won on soft ground, but only over 2 miles. Perfect on the trends, but ground is biggest concern.

*         Movewiththetimes (12/1)
This 8 year old’s last 3 runs are PUF, hardly inspiring. Not won in his 6 chases and off since November.

****   Riders Onthe Storm (7/1)
Yet to win past 2 miles and a way behind Hardline in a Grade 1 Chase on Boxing Day. Short enough in the market.

***** Huntsman Son (25/1)
Improving but is 9 now and only ran 10 days ago.

****   Shady Operator (16/1)
Only 4th last time, but that was over 3 miles. If the ground goes boggy, that stamina may prove crucial. Hasn’t actually won over 2m4 yet.

***** Good Man Pat (16/1)
3rd in a Grade 2 last time. Hasn’t faced a big field yet. And has won over 3 miles on heavy too, so they might be too quick for him if the rain doesn’t come.

***     Solomn Grundy (25/1)
9 year old with 7 starts now. Ran over 3m5 last time, so can’t believe this will suit.

***** Quamino (22/1)
Looks a good profile, but been running on good ground. Not sure he’ll stay in a bog.

***** Dell Oro (40/1)
Top 3 last time, but a 64 length beating behind Glen Forsa and Kalashnikov isn’t quite what I had in mind. Another who’s been running on Good ground.




Conclusion
Another devilish handicap to solve. A lot of the trend horses have been running on good ground over the winter, so anything soft or heavy will mean a rethink. I do like A Plus Tard, but blimey he’s a bit short now. Good Man Pat misses out, form in small fields and I can’t remember the last festival winner Alan King had.

Selections
HIGHWAY ONE O ONE @ 12/1 general, 6 places Skybet
SHADY OPERATOR @ 20/1 William Hill, 16/1 general.




NATIONAL HUNT CHALLENGE CUP
AMATEUR RIDERS’ NOVICES’ CHASE
3 Miles 7 Furlongs 170 Yards, Grade 2 Novice Chase


Overview
Rathvinden became the first 10 year old to win for 16 years, beating our selection, Ms Parfois. The quality of the horses has improved significantly over the last few years, leading to an upgrade from a Class 2 race in 2014 to a Grade 2 event in 2017. The last 8 renewals are the most relevant to today’s race.


Last 10 Winners- average 4.4 stars
2018  ****    Rathvinden (9/2)
2017  *****  Tiger Roll (16/1)
2016  *****  Minella Rocco (8/1)
2015  ****    Cause Of Causes (8/1)
2014  ***      Midnight Prayer (8/1)
2013  *****  Back In Focus (9/4 fav)
2012  *****  Teaforthree (5/1 fav)
2011  *****  Chicago Grey (5/1 fav)
2010  *****  Poker De Sivola (14/1)
2009  ***      Tricky Trickster (11/1)


10-Year Trends
10/10 Had raced over fences at least 3 times.
10/10 Had finished in the top 2 in a Chase over at least 2 miles 71/2 furlongs.
10/10 Had finished in the top 5 last time.
  9/10 Had achieved a hurdles rating of 125 or more in their career. [Midnight Prayer 121 in 2014]
  9/10 Had won over at least 3 miles in any sphere. [Cause Of Causes was 2nd the Festival before in a 3m11/2f Chase]
  8/10 Were aged between 6 and 8 years old. [Exceptions 9 & 10]
  8/10 Had been off the track for between 24 and 78 days. [Exceptions 18 & 134 days]
  8/10 Had raced in a Graded Chase. [Exceptions won Class 2 & 3 Chases]
  8/10 Had an Adjusted RPR of 154+. [The last 8. 7 of those were 159+] [OR 139+]
  8/10 Had finished in the top 2 in one of their last 2 starts. [Exceptions DNF & 5th]
  8/10 Were rated within 8lbs of the RPR Top Rated horse. [Exceptions 12 & 18lbs]

Waiting on the sidelines at this extreme trip is a Sire stat:
10/10 Were by a Sire who's stamina index was 11.7 furlongs or more. (Or Dam’s Sire if no rating.)


Additionally
The last 18 winners had at least 3 starts over fences.
19 of the last 20 winners had finished in the top 2 in a 3 mile Chase.
19 of the last 21 winners had finished in the top 4 in their last 2 starts.
18 of the last 19 winners has run between 4 and 8 times that season.
11 of the last 17 winners had finished in the top 2 last time.
Since 1989, only two 6 year olds had won the race (2009 and 2016)


Ages (Wins-Places-Runners)
  5yo  0-0-1
  6yo  2-2-21
  7yo  3-9-73
  8yo  3-7-54
  9yo  1-1-16
10yo  1-1-8
12yo  0-0-1


Trainers (Wins-Places-Runners)
Gordon Elliott (Ire) 3-0-7
Willie Mullins (Ire) 2-3-13
Colin Tizzard 0-2-2
Henry Daly 1-0-3
Mouse Morris (Ire) 0-1-3
Warren Greatrex 0-1-4
Nicky Henderson 0-1-4
David Pipe 0-1-5


Contenders
***** Ballyward (11/4 fav)
He’s only had 2 Chase starts, that is the major stumbling block in backing him at such a short price. If he’d got one more run inside him, he’d be the pick. But he hasn’t.

**       Beyond The Law (66/1)
Doesn’t jump out as a 4 mile horse, as he’s been running over 2m5f or so. Only ran 16 days ago and was a disappointing 6th. Hard to recommend.

****   Chef Des Obeaux (18/1)
Only ran 17 days ago and has yet to race at Graded level.

*         Clondaw Cian (200/1)
form of 0PP300 doesn’t inspire me with any confidence.

***     Discorama (6/1)
Fell last time, which knocks him down in the trends, but could have beaten Ballyward. Can’t be ruled out.

***     Gun Digger (14/1)
Been running over 21/2m and is opposed.

****   Impulsive Star (16/1)
Good win in an open handicap last time out over 3m5f. 4th in this last year. That experience will be very useful. Isn’t rated as highly as most winners and is now 9 years old.

***** Jerrysback (10/1)
5 stars, but only racing at 3 miles or more was in his Point-to-Point career. Has to be passed over in this.

*         Johanos (100/1)
4th on only Chase start to date. Easily opposed.

*         Just Your Type (40/1)
Doesn’t win too much, and only ran 17 days ago. Another opposed.

****   Le Breuil (14/1)
Jamie Codd is on board. Not winning over about 2m4, so needs to prove himself and Sire Stats say he won’t stay.

****   Mulcahys Hill (33/1)
Not rated high enough, and form over 3 miles is poor. Sire Stats say he won’t stay as well.

****   Ok Corral (10/3)
A Favourite with only 2 Chase starts, beating only 6 horses in the process, he has to be taken on. Although a 10 year old won last year, I’m still opposing him on age grounds as well.

**       Plantagenet (200/1)
Good form at much lower levels, more required. Only ran 15 days ago.

****   Skipthecuddles (40/1)
Found wanting in graded company and won a match last time. More needed.

***     Warthog (100/1)
Form is over 21/2m, so a leap of faith required in this.

****   Whisperinthebreeze (16/1)
Another running over an intermediate trip, but has got placed form in his only try at 3 m 1f. Won an open handicap last time, can’t be ruled out.

****   Atlanta Ablaze (14/1)
Hurdles rating wasn’t good and only been running is Listed Mares Chases, but is pretty experienced and should be on the shortlist. Gets a handy 7lbs allowance.

Contenders
Experience is a key and the 2 leading fancies have only 2 runs each. There are holes is plenty of the others as well. Discorama fell last time, but had a good chance of winning at the time. Impulsive Star was 4th last year and has been won an open company last time. Ballyward is great on the trends apart from an important one.

Selection
IMPULSIVE STAR @ 16/1, Bet365, Betfred, totesport, BetVictor all 4 places.





No comments: