Fulke
Walwyn Kim Muir Challenge Cup (Amateur Riders' H'cap Chase) –
Class 2 – 3m 11/2f
Can Same Difference (right) win back to back renewals.
Overview:
Strong trends,
but weight not so much an issue this year. Should be able to find
something competitive.
10-Year
Trends
10/10 Were rate
within 8lbs of the RPR top rated horse.
10/10 Had run
over 3 miles or more last time.
10/10 Had won a
Chase.
10/10 Had run
within 78 Days.
9/10 Were
rated officially between 124 and 140.
9/10 Aged
between 7 and 9.
8/10 Had won
a Chase over at least 3 miles.
8/10 Finished
in the top 3 last time.
7/10 Had run
in fewer than 12 chases. The last 7 winners.
Additionally
15
of the last 20 winners were aged 8 or 9.
The
last 13 winners had run over 3 miles or more last time out.
Ireland
haven't won this in the last 30 renewals.
Ages
(Wins-Places-Runners)
5yo 0-0-1
6yo 0-2-15
7yo 2-9-53
8yo 2-3-55
9yo 5-8-48
10yo 1-7-33
11yo 0-0-15
12yo 0-0-10
13yo 0-1-4
Contenders –
10 year trends
winner averaged 4.1
stars
Roberto
Goldback 18/1 **
Too
old and too high in the weights, probably. Trip/Ground are fine, but
at 12 he's is TOO old.
Tranquil
Sea 20/1 **
Form of his win in a Veteran's chase not working out
(Time For Rupert flopped) and is also 12.
Twirling
Magnet 14/1 ****
Off for 131 days is not good. But avoided bad ground in
the meantime. Won here on the ground and the distance in the autumn.
Chance.
Our
Father 20/1 ***
All wins on softer, looks a bit of a plodder who wants
further. First time blinkers *shrug*
Buddy
Bolero 16/1 *****
Not a great run on good ground in December, so trust
will have to taken on that. First time blinkers are on.
Same
Difference 18/1 ****
Won last year, and now only 4lbs higher. Ground will be
fine and can run another big race.
Indian
Castle 13/2fav ***
Ground, trip, course no problem, but is only 6. All
winners in the last 10 have come from at least 3 miles last time,
however with the bad ground around, maybe they wanted him to get a
run in and not kill him.
Cause
Of Causes 15/2 **
How short is this one. 6 year old, no win in 7 chases
and only ever won at about 2 miles. Good run last time at 3 miles
though but fails many trends.
Lost
Glory 40/1 ***
Trip fine,ground fine, but very poor last 2 on good
ground. Off for 89 days as well.
Swing
Bill 40/1 **
He must want further (2 good runs in Grand National),
but too old (13) and too exposed and off for 3 months.
Spring
Heeled 16/1 *****
Out of form on conditions that should suit. No wins past
2m5 either.
Dursey
Sound (NR)
Balnaslow 10/1 *****
Only
point-to-point form at this distance, but place chances on his latest
form.
Saint
Are 40/1 ***
Don't think he's a 3 miler at Cheltenham, and off for
nearly 4 months.
Mumbles
Head 66/1 **
13 year old, who's been off for ages. Ground/trip fone,
but not run at Cheltenham since him bumper days.
Fine
Parchment 50/1 *
Doesn't look good enough at 11yo and exposed, but has
form on ground and trip this season but last time wasn't inspiring.
Pickamus 66/1 ***
Trip/ground fine, but humped last time and record at
Cheltenham doesn't inspire confidence for this 11yo.
There's
No Panic 16/1 ****
Off the track for 96 days is a negative, but isn't too
bad and is shortlisted.
Night
Alliance 33/1 *****
Perfect on the trends. Pulled-Up last time on heavy, but
has a chance today.
Tabhachtach 33/1 **
looks about ½ mile too far for him. No thanks.
Gas
Line Boy 33/1 ****
85 days off not great, loos short of expereince, and
well humped last time. No ins on ground this fast either.
Quinz 33/1 **
Too old now and no wins for 3 years.
Hunting
Party 25/1 ***
Don't think he'll get the trip
Problema
Tic 33/1 ***
Out
of form. Should get the trip on the ground, but has had it this
season and flopped. Also off for a tad too long.
Conclusions
Narrowed it
down to 5 for the shortlist.
SAME
DIFFERENCE (18/1, bet365, 5 pl) is weighted to repeat the feat or at
least get pretty close.
THERE'S NO
PANIC (16/1, bet365, 5pl) has
been off for long than any of the last 10 winners, but has a chance
if he's fit.
NIGHT
ALLIANCE (33/1, Bet365, Stan
James, 5pl) is perfect, but needs to bounce back today, but at
33/1 its a chance we can take.
Balnaslow
(10/1) is too short to bet e/w, so just a watching brief there.
Indian
Castle (13/2fav) is also too short but is placepot material.