Monday 9 March 2020

Cheltenham 2020 - Day One


SKY BET SUPREME NOVICES' HURDLE
2 Miles 87 Yards, Grade 1 Novice Hurdle


Overview
Last year, Willie Mullins’ Klassical Dream drifted like a barge in the run up to the race. He failed a couple of lesser trends, but was 2 from 2 for Willie Mullins after coming over from France. Strong Graded form still holds sway. This years renewal looks a cracker on paper.


Last 10 Winners- average 4.4 stars
2019  ****    Klassical Dream (6/1)
2018  *****  Summerville Boy (9/1)
2017  **        Labaik (25/1)
2016  *****  Altior (4/1)
2015  *****  Douvan (2/1 fav)
2014  *****  Vautour (7/2 jt fav)
2013  *****  Champagne Fever (5/1)
2012  *****  Cinders And Ashes (10/1)
2011  ****    Al Ferof (10/1)
2010  ****    Menorah (12/1)


10-year Trends
10/10 Had won over 2 miles.
10/10 Were aged 5 or 6. [1 placed horse from 20 runners outside of this age group]
  9/10 Had run between 4 and 5 times over hurdles. [Klassical Dream had 7 runs (5 in France, 2 in Ireland)]
  9/10 Had run less than 11 times in total in their career. [Labaik had 15, but refused to start in 6 of the last 8, flat and jumps]
  9/10 Had an Adjusted Racing Post Rating (A.RPR) of at least 150. All had an Official Rating (OR) of 142+. [Al Ferof, A.RPR of 146]
  9/10 Had run within the last 67 days. [Altior (80 days]
  9/10 Were not flat-bred horses. [Labaik started on the flat, Klassical Dream did run on he flat as a 3 year old after Hurdles debut]
  8/10 Had won last time out (LTO). [Menorah, 2nd in 2010 and Labaik (RR), but won his last 'race']
  8/10 Were rated within 10lbs of the Top A.RPR rated horse.
  8/10 Had won a Grade 1 or Grade 2 Hurdle. 8 of the last 9 winners had achieved this. [Menorah winning a Class 2 Hurdle. Labaik, a Grade 3, had refused in 2 Grade 1&2 races]
  7/10 Had won at least 50% of their hurdles. [Exceptions the last 3 years, 2 had ‘reasons’]


Additionally
Only one 4-year old has won in the last 45 years.[Hors La Loi III in 1999]
41 of the last 45 winners were aged 5 or 6.
23 of the last 25 winners had run within the last 68 days. 19 of those, within the last 45 days.
20 of the last 23 winners had won last time.
14 of the last 16 winners had run in 4 or more hurdles races.
Flown (blinkered) in 1992, was the last horse to win with headgear. 35 horses beaten. He’s also the last horse to win after just one hurdle run.


Ages (Win-Place-Runs)
4yo 0-0-3
5yo 5-13-76
6yo 5-6-61
7yo 0-1-12
8yo 0-0-4
9yo 0-0-1


Trainers (Win-Place-Runs)
Willie Mullins (Ire) 4-3-27
Nicky Henderson 1-8-19
Gordon Elliott (Ire) 1-1-6
Henry De Bromhead (Ire) 0-1-4


Contenders
*****  Abacadabras (11/2)
Only beaten by Envoi Allen (Ballymore favourite) so far this season and has Grade 1 winning form in the book. 4th in the Bumper last season, so track should be fine, only slight worry is he’s been off since Christmas, when he really need to be racing.


****    Allart (18/1)
2 wins at a low level since a fall on debut, however the Supreme winners of late have has at least 4 hurdles runs. Lack of Graded form means he’s overlooked here.

*****  Asterion Forlonge (11/4 jt fav)
Cruised to victories in both starts, the last by 9 length in a Grade 1 at the Dublin Festival. 2 runs is a negative in the hustle and bustle of this race.


*          Berkshire Royal (33/1)
Not seen a hurdle in public, so difficult to assess on that. You can’t dismiss a Willie Mullins horse, but he’s been off the track for nearly 2 years, so I will oppose him here.

***      Captain Guinness (14/1)
Probably needed another run, after he was just touched off in a Grade 2 on 2nd and last start.


***      Chantry House (13/2)
Beat a next time Grade 2 winner on debut here, getting 6lbs. (Stolen Silver went on to win the Haydock Trail, beating Edwardstown by a neck.). A lack of Graded form and just the 2 runs are negatives.


***      Edwardstone (16/1)
3 runs so far. Beat Fiddlerontheroof on debut, and then the decent Harry Senior next time. Before beaten by Stolen Silver above.


***      Elixir D’Ainay (22/1)
Front-runner and looks all about stamina, with recent runs over further, you’d imagine it would have to be a bog to be hitting the frame here.


*****  Fiddlerontheroof (13/2)
Beaten by horses on first 2 starts, but won last time in the Grade 1 Tolworth, at Sandown, by 6 lengths. Perfect trendswise. Will be up with the pace in this hot contest.


*          Hollow Sound (150/1)
Will have to improve on debut 3rd. Unlikely to do so in this.


*          Jabbaar (200/1)
Should be outclassed here.

**        Mario Du Pail (100/1)
Beaten in a Class4 last time, and not good enough.

****    Shishkin (11/4 jt fav)
Fell on debut, before 2 solid wins at a lower level. Drops off with a lack of Graded win and just 3 starts. Ran at Huntingdon last time (as Nicky Henderson has done with Get Me Out Of Here and Buveur D’Air before getting beaten in this race.) He may be quality, but he’s no price in this.


***      Soviet Pimpernel (33/1)
Won a Grade 3 event last time, after a 20 length beating by Envoi Allen and Abacadabra in a hot Grade 1. He may improve for that on softer ground here, but will find a few too hot.


***      Whatsnotoknow (100/1)
Better than some at a price, but form is on better ground. Just not good enough.


**        Heaven Help Us (100/1)
Beaten by Abacadabras 2 runs ago (8 lengths). Only 3rd in a Mares Listed event last time. Not good enough.


Conclusion
Looks a hot heat with plenty of dross in it as well, lets hope they don’t get in the way.
Probably best to keep it simple and not look for a double figure price.


Selection
There looks a lot of pace on in this and while Fiddlerontheroof is perfect on trends, he may get taken on up front. I’ll oppose Asteron Forlonge on his lack of experience and Shishkin on lack of Graded form. ABACADABRAS (11/2) may have run into the best 2 mile novice around this season, and without Envoi Allen in this race, his
waited with style is chosen to pick off the rest with a clear run.

Bookies Offers
William Hill offering 7 places for this race. Skybet giving a free bet of up to £10 if your horse loses.




RACING POST ARKLE CHALLENGE TROPHY
NOVICES' CHASE
1 Mile 7 Furlongs 199 Yards, Grade 1 Novice Chase


Overview
Last year’s race wasn’t a classic, the worthy winner has been dreadful this season. Only 3 horses have won since (none of the first 7). This year’s looks the same with only a couple of horses showing Arkle winning form.


Last 10 Winners- average 4.5 stars
2019  ***      Duc Des Genievres (5/1)
2018  *****  Footpad (5/6 fav)
2017  *****  Altior (1/4 fav)
2016  *****  Douvan (1/4 fav)
2015  *****  Un De Sceaux (4/6 fav)
2014  **        Western Warhorse (33/1)
2013  *****  Simonsig (8/15 fav)
2012  *****  Sprinter Sacre (8/15 fav)
2011  *****  Captain Chris (6/1)
2010  *****  Sizing Europe (6/1)


10-year Trends
10/10 Had run within the last 80 days.
10/10 Were not flat-bred horses.
10/10 Had won last time.
  9/10 Top 2 in all Chase finishes.[Exception: Duc Des Genievres (3rd)]
  9/10 Aged 6 or 7 years old. [Sizing Europe won, aged 8, in 2010.]
  9/10 Had an Adjusted RPR of 163 or more. (OR 151+) [Western Warhorse (148), but had only 1 chase start]
  9/10 Rated within 6lbs of the RPR Top Rated. [Western Warhorse (23lbs) in 2014]
  9/10 Ran to a Hurdles rating of 149 or more. [Western Warhorse 130]
  8/10 Won a Novice Chase between 2m and 2m3f. Both exception won at 2m4 & 2m41/2f.
  8/10 Had 3/4 Chase starts. Both exceptions less.
  7/10 Had a course win or had a top 3 finish at a previous festival.


Additionally
31 of the last 33 winners had finished 1st or 2nd on their last start.
27 of the last 28 winners started at 9/1 or less.
20 of the last 22 winners had not unseated/fallen in their chase career.
19 of the last 21 winners were aged 5-7.
18 of the last 20 winners had a hurdles rating of 142+,


Ages (Wins-Places-Runners)
  5yo 0-0-3
  6yo 5-4-24
  7yo 4-9-41
  8yo 1-2-11
  9yo 0-1-8
10yo 0-0-1


Trainers (Wins-Places-Runners)
Willie Mullins (Ire) 4-1-10
Henry de Bromhead (Ire) 1-2-9
Joseph O’Brien (Ire) 0-1-1


Contenders
***      Al Dancer (16/1)
4 runs in small fields, been running in the right races, but just not good enough so far.



***      Brewinupastorm (11/2)
Off the track too long, and no Graded form in his 2 runs. I'm not a fan at this price.



**        Cash Back (6/1)
Ran Notebook to less than a length in the Irish Arkle at Leopardstown, but he an 8 year old, and hasn’t experience of the track.



****    Esprit Du Large (12/1)
Ticks plenty of boxes, but has been off for 3 months. Winner of the Grade 1, Henry VIII Chase at Sandown, when last seen. Wasn’t a great hurdler (only 3 in this race hit that trend this year). Plenty of winners of this have stamina over further, and this could be on his side here.

*          Fakir D’Oudaries (4/1)
Only a 5 year old, and looked great on first 2 starts, winning a Grade 1 by 22 lengths, but ran into Notebook last time, getting 7lbs which he won’t get here. 1 star is very harsh, but place chances at best.

**        Global Citizen (12/1)
Good hurdler, and has beaten Rough Vif on his last run in December.


****    Notebook (3/1 fav)
Hasn’t done anything wrong so far. He wasn’t anything special over hurdles, and his 12th in the Ballymore last year (50/1 shot) means he has to prove it at Cheltenham. Been very edgy before the start of his races, but the best horse in this on what we’ve seen.

*          Our Merlin (100/1)
Won his only start in a handicap, and they have a poor record in Grade 1’s here. Easy to pass over.

***      Rouge Vif (14/1)
Getting better with every race, including a Grade 2 win last time. Also a Grade 2 winner over hurdles, but last of 4 on first spin round here on 2nd start. Both wins have come on good to soft, with both his defeats on soft.



***      Maire Banrigh (11/1)
8 year old. She ran at Huntingdon on last start, but has won all 4 of her races. Not sure she’s beaten anything though and this will be a lot tougher.



***      Put The Kettle On (18/1)
Won the Arkle Trial in November (beating Al Dancer). Off since and need more to win this.




Conclusion
There looks to be a lot of pace on in this. The Arkle is usually a smaller field so being up with the pace hasn’t been a problem, though the went off far too fast in Footpad’s Arkle. I don’t think you want to be too far behind though so some interesting decisions will have to be made by the jockeys. It’s not a vintage renewal this year.


Selection
NOTEBOOK has done all that is asked of him so far, he’ll have earplugs in at the start to calm him down. 3/1 is a fair price. 

 





ULTIMA HANDICAP CHASE
3m 1f, Grade 3 Handicap Chase


Overview
The first handicap of the festival and the trends are opposing the favourite Vinndication. Its a race where previous festival form, especially in this race, is a big plus. Lovely stuff.


Last 10 Winners- average 3.9 stars
2019  ***      Beware The Bear (10/1)
2018  *****  Coo Star Sivola (5/1 fav)
2017  ****    Un Temps Pour Tout (9/1)
2016  *****  Un Temps Pour Tout (11/1)
2015  ***      The Druids Nephew (8/1)
2014  *****  Holywell (10/1)
2013  **        Golden Chieftain (28/1)
2012  ***      Alfie Sherrin (14/1)
2011  *****  Bensalem (5/1)
2010  ****    Chief Dan George (33/1)


10-year Trends
10/10 Won over 2 miles 71/2 furlongs or more.
  9/10 Aged between 6 and 9 years old [The last 9 winners.]
  9/10 Had run between 2 and 5 times that season. [Golden Chieftain racked up 7 before winning this]
  9/10 Had achieved a Chase RPR of 143. [Alfie Sherrin was the lowest rated winner (135)]
  9/10 Had run within the last 47 days. [Beware The Bear was off for 70 days having won here on New Year’s Day]
  9/10 Had run at a previous Festival. [Exception: Golden Chieftain.]
  8/10 OR no bigger than 148. [Previous winner Un Temps Pour Tout (155) & Beware The Bear (151)]
  8/10 Finished in the top 3 in one of the last 2 starts. 2 winners were unplaced in decent Hurdle races last time.
  8/10 Had run less than 10 times over fences. [None more than 14 starts.]


Additionally
The last 14 winners had between 2 & 7 runs that season.
20 of the last 21 winners were aged between 7 and 10.
18 of the last 20 winners had won over 3 miles or more.
Only two horses, aged 11 or more, have placed since 1997.
No Irish-Trained winner since 2006. Only 2 since 1967.


Ages (Wins-Places-Runners)
  6yo 1-3-15
  7yo 2-9-43
  8yo 4-4-59
  9yo 2-9-61
10yo 1-2-24
11yo 0-2-14
12yo 0-0-4
13yo 0-0-1


Trainers (Wins-Places-Runners)
Jonjo O'Neill 2-1-13
Nicky Henderson 1-3-13
Neil Mulholland 1-1-8
Alan King 1-1-8
Colin Tizzard 1-0-12
Lucinda Russell 0-2-3
Sue Smith 0-2-7
Gordon Elliott (Ire) 0-1-4
Philip Hobbs 0-1-4
Tom George 0-1-6

Contenders
**        Vinndication (6/1 fav)
Its a race where a recent run is a major plus, he’s had just 1 run this season and is too high in the weights after an 8lb rise for his win in November.


***      Brave Eagle (20/1)
Another off the track for over 3 months, and is high in the weights. His run was disappointing in the Martin Pipe when he ran here in 2018.


*          Cepage (16/1)
No form over 3 miles and a few too many runs for this.

****    Vintage Clouds (16/1)
Up a few lbs and now 10, but placed the last 2 years, so a good run can be expected. Can’t see him winning now.

*****  Mister Malarky (9/1)
He’d have a lovely weight if he hadn’t won last time. Ticks all of the boxes apart from that. He’s been a hard horse to get right, and to win 2 in a9 row would be some feat.

****    Kildisart (8/1)
Consistent without placing, needs help from the handicapper.

***      Discorama (8/1)
2nd in the 4 miler last year, but has yet to win over 3 miles (won only once so far). Been off since Christmas (and that was a hurdle), so short enough in this.


***      Who Dares Wins (10/1)
Novice Chasing after a decent flat career, so would be an unusual winner. Lack of any form over this far means he’ll be passed over.

***      Atlanta Ablaze (22/1)
She got pummelled 45 lengths last time, but steps back up to a preferred 3 miles. Seems to struggle in big fields, and has to be ignored.

*          Activial (20/1)
Too old (at 10) and out of form recently. Form is over shorter and shouldn’t be winning)

*****  Mulcahys Hill (16/1)
Fell, when tired in the 4 miler last year. Ticks all the right boxes, but doesn’t want it drying out too much.

****    Burbank (20/1)
Disappointed in the Coral Cup last season and hasn’t shown a liking for 3 miles yet.


***      Cogry (25/1)
Old timer, who is ultra consistent. 33 runs now and if he was going to win, it would have been 2 years ago when he was 11th. Place chance though.


**        Townshend (40/1)
Been running ok, but with only 1 run so far this season, and no form here, its hard to make a case for him today.


***      Cobra De Mai (16/1)
He’s has a poor season, but is dropping down the handicap to a winning weight. He’s had a lot of runs and no experience of the festival in all these years.


***      Big River (25/1)
Now a 10 year old, he’s better than a 3 star. Proven stamina and 4th last year.


****    The Conditional (9/1)
Had a Gold Cup entry. That may have been a bit of a leap, but another who is ultra consistent at this trip. He has no festival experience, but won here in October (over C & D) and is a lovely weight.

*          Elwood (16/1)
Had a lot of runs this season, and is Irish-trained (poor record). Been running well in Graded Chases over the sea, so not unproven at he trip yet, but can’t recommend.

*          Soupy Soups (33/1)
Plenty of runs this season and in his career. 4 months off and no festival experience.

****    Quarenta (25/1)
Ticks plenty of boxes. No festival experience and only visits were poor over hurdles.


***      No Comment (20/1)
No winning form at this trip, but has run well at previous festivals, so no surprise to see him 5th or 6th here.


General Principle – non runner


*          Vivas (66/1)
3lbs out of the handicap. Shouldn’t be troubling the scorers here. No for at this trip and basically not good enough on what he’s shown us.


***      Ice Cool Champs (100/1)
4lbs out of the handicap. Fares a little better but, not good enough as well.


Conclusion
Obviously its a hard race, but THE CONDITIONAL, looks far too big a price at 9/1 here. He has to go close, surely. The other I’m picking is MULCAHYS HILL, who looks the tight profile, lets hope it does rain on monday to help him out. Other who ran well last year are Vintage Clouds and Big River.


Selections
THE CONDITIONAL is 9/1 at the moment with Bet365 and William Hill
MULCAHYS HILL is 25/1 e/w at Coral and William Hill (5 places at moment).




UNIBET CHAMPION HURDLE CHALLENGE TROPHY
2 Miles 87 Yards, Grade 1 Hurdle


Overview
Espoir D’Allen, was a terrible advert for the trends, being only the 2nd five year old to win in 34 years. There were many under-performances and an early fall by the champion, but he won very easily in the end. The 15 length victory being the largest in the race’s history. This year’s renewal looks especially open - ie terrible - without the new champion, who sadly died in the summer.
.

Last 10 Winners- average 3.7 stars
2019  *          Espoir D’Allen (16/1)
2018  *****  Buveur D'Air (4/6 fav)
2017  ****    Buveur D'Air (5/1)
2016  ****    Annie Power (5/2 fav)
2015  ****    Faugheen (4/5 fav)
2014  ****    Jezki (9/1)
2013  ***      Hurricane Fly (13/8 fav)
2012  **        Rock On Ruby (11/1)
2011  *****  Hurricane Fly (11/4 fav)
2010  *****  Binocular (9/1)


10-year Trends
10/10 Had won at the distance.
  9/10 Were rated within 8lbs of the RP Top Rated horse. [Espoir D’Allen (17lbs)]
  9/10 Had between 5 and 12 Hurdle runs. [Hurricane Fly (19) was a previous winner.]
  9/10 Had won a Class 1 Hurdle that season, 6 won a Grade 1. [Annie Power had just 1 prep run before winning]
  8/10 Had an Adjusted RPR of 169 or more. [9/10 OR 162+]. [Buveur D’Air (was Novice Chasing) and Espoir D’Allen]
  8/10 Had won a Grade 1 Hurdle. [Exceptions: Grade 3 & Listed]
  8/10 Were aged between 6 and 8 years old. [Hurricane Fly (9) was a previous winner, Espoir D’Allen (5)]
  8/10 Had run within the last 51 days. All ran within 79 days.
  8/10 Had won last time out. [Exceptions were 2nd & 4th in Grade 1 Hurdles.]


Additionally
28 of the last 30 winners had won that season.
30 of the last 36 winners had won last time.
25 of the last 29 winners were from the first 5 in the betting.
23 of the last 28 winners had placed at a previous festival.
21 of the last 32 winners had won at Cheltenham.
Only 4 9 year-olds have won since 1951.
Sea Pigeon was 10 & 11 in 1980 & 1981. [Aged 10 and older are 0/28 since then]
Only 2 5 year-olds have won since 1985. From 102 runners.
No reigning Supreme Novice Winner has won since 1971.
Since 1993, only 2 winners had not run in that calendar year.


Ages (Wins-Places-Runners)
  5yo  1-2-23
  6yo  3-8-28
  7yo  4-3-22
  8yo  1-4-18
  9yo  1-1-6
10yo  0-1-3
11yo  0-1-2
13yo  0-0-1


Trainers (Wins-Places-Runners)
Willie Mullins (Ire) 4-6-21
Nicky Henderson 3-5-23
Gavin Cromwell (Ire) 1-0-1
Jessica Harrington (Ire)
Nigel Twiston-Davies 0-2-6
Gordon Elliott (Ire) 0-1-2
Evan Williams 0-1-2
Henry De Bromhead (Ire) 0-1-3


Contenders
*          Ballyandy (16/1)
Been around for ages and not ran in this before (3rd in Coral Cup last season). Can’t see him winning now aged 9, but did win a Grade 2 last time.


**        Call Me Lord (20/1)
Beaten last time out, no excuses either. Won the International Hurdle (beating Ballyandy) here but falls short on the trends.


****    Cilaos Emery (6/1)
Back from an good novice chasing career (won G3 & G2 from 3 runs) as this is such a poor renewal. Won the Novice Champion Hurdle 3 seasons ago,. Fails perfection as his only hurdle run of the season (won a Grade 3, beating Darasso by 9 lengths) so his RPR isn’t as high as it needs to be.


**        Coeur Sublime (14/1)
Only a 5 year old (hmmm) and had wind surgery since last run (explains absence), but short of top class at moment. 2nd to Pentland Hills in Triumph Hurdle last season. Well beaten by Sharjah and Petit Mouchoir at Christmas.

***      Cornerstone Lad (33/1)
Shocked Buveur D’Air in the Fighting Fifth Hurdle, ran well in the Champion Hurdle Trial, when only just beaten by Ballyandy and Pentland Hills. Can't be ruled out on ground he’ll relish..


**        Darasso (40/1)
Not good enough even in an event this open. Beaten by a few of these this season.


***      Darver Star (11/1)
Ran really well at Leopardstown, going down to Honeysuckle in the Irish Champion Hurdle. Hasn’t won too much so far but is only a novice and has plenty of stamina, so could be staying on at the end.


*          Fusil Raffles (14/1)
Hasn’t been seen since pulling up at Christmas, Juvenile Grade 1 winner and won a Grade 2 this season. He’s only 5 so this experience will do him well for the future if he’s as good as he looks.


*          Gumball (66/1)
Too high for handicaps now, outclassed here.

*          Le Patriote (100/1)
Similar profile to Gumball, and outclassed here.

*         Not So Sleepy (25/1)
Former top class flat handicapper (won on Derby Day). Routed the field at Ascot in December. Flat run in the Betfair Hurdle was down to the standing start, and could be anything. May get taken on for lead with Petit Mouchoir. Fails lots of the trends, but you never know.

*         Pentland Hills (5/1)
Triumph winner, could make it back to back five year old winners. However, hasn’t done the business in his races so far, even though he’s been cruising, so wind operation could sort it all out. I want him onside as he’s better than most of these.

**       Petit Mouchoir (25/1)
Placed in the race 3 years ago, before a novice chasing career didn’t take off. Back for more but doesn’t win.

***      Sharjah (10/1)
Too bad to be true in the Irish Champion Hurdle (6th, beaten 32 lengths). Brought down by Buveur D’Air’s fall last year, so plenty to prove at the track (8th in 2018 Supreme)

*          Silver Streak (20/1)
3rd last year, consistent this year, but still not ticking the right boxes. Open race and could hit the frame again, but will need plenty to go right.

*          Supasundae (10/1)
Now 10, and has good course form (won Coral Cup in 2017 and 2nd in a Stayers Hurdle.) Also has top class form over 2 miles. Age is always a barrier and was only 4th in the Irish Champion behind Honeysuckle in only run of season. Better than a one star of course and has place chances.

****    Epatante (7/2fav)
Not put a foot wrong all season, done what a Champion Hurdler would do. Been off since Christmas Hurdle win is a negative, and only run at course was 9th in last years Mares Novices’ Hurdle when favourite, but trainer puts that down to horse flu jab.


Conclusion
Interesting to note that no horse in the race reaches the pre-race threshold that 8 of the last 10 winners had. An APR of 169+. Can’t put you off anything, but EPATANTE ticks more boxes than most. CILAOS EMERY has come back from a fruitful novice chasing career to be supplemented for this and these are the only 2 bullets I’ll fire at the race.




Selections
EPATANTE, generally available at 7/2
CILAOS EMERY is 7/1 with William Hill.





CLOSE BROTHERS MARES’ HURDLE
(REGISTERED AS THE DAVID NICHOLSON MARES’ HURDLE)
2 Miles 3 Furlongs, 200 Yards, Grade 1 Hurdle


Overview
The Willie Mullins benefit, would have had its 10th winner in the 12 runnings of the race, but Benie Des Dieux did an “Annie Power” and with no 2nd string sitting in behind, Roksana, for Dan Skelton, scooped the prize. The trends may still be skewed due to Quevega featuring 5 times, but Mullins still runs his best mares here.


Last 10 Winners- average 4.6 stars
2019  ***      Roksana (10/1)
2018  *****  Benie Des Dieux (9/2)
2017  ****    Apple’s Jade (7/2)
2016  *****  Vroum Vroum Mag (4/6 fav)
2015  *****  Glens Melody (6/1)
2014  *****  Quevega (8/11 fav)
2013  *****  Quevega (8/11 fav)
2012  *****  Quevega (4/7 fav)
2011  *****  Quevega (5/6 fav)
2010  ****    Quevega (6/4 fav)


10-year Trends
10/10 Aged between 5 and 7 years old or were a previous winner. [Quevega won as a 8,9 & 10 year old]
10/10 Raced between 4 and 17 times over Hurdles. [4-10 hurdles without Quevega and a lucky Glenn’s Melody.]
10/10 Rated within 14lbs of RP Top Rated. [9/10 Top Rated if the fallers had stood up.]
10/10 Won over 2m4f or more.
10/10 Had won a race worth £22k.
10/10 Were either French or Irish-bred.
  9/10 Had an Adjusted RPR of at least 156. [OR 147+] [Roksana 153/142]
  7/10 Won last time.


Ages (Wins-Places-Runners)
  4yo  0-0-2
  5yo  2-1-22
  6yo  1-8-50
  7yo  4-4-44
  8yo  1-6-35
  9yo  1-0-8
10yo  1-0-3
11yo  0-0-1


Trainers (Wins-Places-Runners)
Willie Mullins (Ire) 8-5-20
Dan Skelton 1-0-4

.
Contenders
*****  Benie Des Dieux (4/6 fav)
Worthy favourite, a little older than I’d like, but best horse in the race on ratings

*          Cap Soleil (66/1)
Outclassed

*          Crossgalesfamegame (100/1)
Outclassed

*          Desaray Girl (100/1)
Outclassed

**        Elfile (20/1)
Could run into a place. But can’t win.

****    Honeysuckle (9/4)
Up and coming mare with plenty in her favour, has a little to find with Benie De Dieux, but still improvement in her.

*          Lady Buttons (16/1)
Now 10 and could have run in the Champion Chase or other handicaps. Plenty to find with the best of these. 4th last year.

**        Popong (100/1)
Sure to be outclassed.


*****  Roksana (9/1)
Lucky to win last year, needs something similar to happen to win this year.


*****  Stormy Ireland (12/1)
2nd last year, will be there or there abouts, but plenty to find with the top 2 in the market.


Conclusion
A much smaller field than normal, mainly because of the front 2 in the market. Can’t see past BENIE DE DIEUX at this trip. Honeysuckle for the forecast.


Selection
No bet




NORTHERN TRUST COMPANY NOVICES’ HANDICAP CHASE
2 Miles 4 Furlongs, 78 Yards, Listed Novice Chase


Overview
A Plus Tard was a 4 star fancy last year, but has been regraded to 2 stars. This sort of handicap, still in its infancy, is sure to be every changing. Remember these are up and coming, in-form, Novices. Not quite good enough to run in the JLT, but luckily falling within the correct OR to run in this easier contest. The Mares Chase (pencilled in for 2021) may well replace this race, forcing more horses into the JLT/Marsh or other Grade 1 Novice Chases.


Last 10 Winners- average 3.8 stars
2019  **        A Plus Tard (5/1 fav)
2018  *****  Mister Whitaker (13/2)
2017  ***      Tully East (8/1)
2016  ****    Ballyalton (12/1)
2015  ****    Irish Cavalier (11/1)
2014  *****  Present View (8/1)
2013  ****    Rajdhani Express (16/1)
2012  ***      Hunt Ball (13/2 fav)
2011  *****  Divers (10/1)
2010  *****  Copper Bleu (12/1)


10-year Trends
10/10 Had won at least a Class 3 Chase or Hurdle.
10/10 Had last run within the last 59 days.
  9/10 Had finished in the top 3 last time they completed. [Rajdhani Express was 7th]
  9/10 Had raced over fences between 3 and 5 times. [Hunt Ball (9)]
  9/10 Hadn't won more than 2 chases. [Hunt Ball won 6 as he went 50lbs up the ratings.]
  7/10 Had not run in a Graded Chase so far. [3 of the last 4 had.]
  7/10 Aged 6 or 7. [Others were 5, 8 & 9]
  7/10 Had won over at least 2m 4f.


Additionally
Only 1 horse that carried a penalty ran into a place.
Since the start, 6 & 7 year olds have won 11 renewals (and 26 places) from 174 runners, all other ages are 4 from 120 (19 places).
Horses in first time head-gear have placed 7 times in the last 11 renewals.


Ages (Wins-Places-Runners)
  5yo 1-1-12
  6yo 4-7-47
  7yo 3-12-71
  8yo 1-6-47
  9yo 1-4-19
10yo 0-0-2


Trainers (Wins-Places-Runners)
Nicky Henderson 1-4-18
Colin Tizzard 0-2-7
Noel Meade (0-1-2)
Dan Skelton 0-1-3
Gordon Elliott (Ire) 0-1-7
Venitia Williams 0-1-8


Contenders
****    Precious Cargo (12/1)
Ticks plenty of boxes, but no winning for at the distance a big worry, on soft ground.
***      Hold The Note (15/2)
Yet to win anything special, and fails some trends by just a little.

****    Espoir De Guye (11/1)
Being off for 80 days is a negative and has won just shy of the distance.

**        Torpillo (12/1)
4th and 5th in out of form in this contest, and is not quite the age bracket I’m after. Also more of a 2 miler.


****    Knight In Dubai (20/1)
Ticks lots of boxes but yet to win a Class 3 or above race.

****    Jarveys Plate (33/1)
terrible run last time, in fact out of the frame on last 3 starts.

*****  Champagne Mystery (25/1)
More like it, perfect on the trends. Consistent as well, but untested in big fields.

*****  Imperial Aura (9/2 fav)
Rock solid form behind Simply The Betts here last time. Stamina not an issue.

****    Champagne Court (14/1)
5th (21 lengths) in the Simply The Betts race, not enough pull in the weights to turn that around. Ticks the rest of the boxes though.

***      Galvin (7/1)
Off for 3 months and form is at 2 miles.


***      Paint The Dream (20/1)
Ludlow is another poor performing prep run track, 5th there doesn’t help matters.

****    Highest Sun (20/1)
Well beaten the last 2 runs. Winning form over 3 miles, and none at this trip.

***      Mellow Ben (40/1)
Another well beaten in last 2 starts. Look elsewhere.


****    Earlofthecotswolds (25/1)
3 months is a long time off in this race, not sure he’ll be ready for it, but plenty to like about him otherwise.

****    Beakstown (12/1)
Grade 2 winning hurdler, and in his 3 chases has lost to Sam Spinner, Champ and Mister Fisher, so hot company indeed. Similar to ‘The Earl’ above, off for 3 months is not a positive here.

***      Mitchouka (33/1)
Busy this season and winning form is at 2 miles, though has raced over 3 miles at the end if his hurdling career (7th and 16th).


****    Daly Tiger (25/1)
Lack of 2m4f form is a worry, but was 3rd in a Graded Chase over the trip.


**        Lord Schnitzel (28/1)
No wins of any description in his career. Difficult to recommend.



**        De Plotting Shed (40/1)
Punted in favourite in this 2 years ago. Broke his duck in the summer, beating Mellow Ben. Now a 10 year old with 14 chase starts, his time has gone.


**        Trainwreck (11/1)
Good run over 2m5f last time, but busy this season, and is now 8.


***      Whatmore (16/1) - Reserve.


*****  Sensulano (20/1) - Reserve. Interesting if she ran.


Conclusion
A tough ‘handicap’ to solve. Just 7lbs between top and bottom. Although the early winners hadn’t contested Graded Chases, 3 of the last 4 had. Being considered good enough to enter then run against some classy horses can’t be a bad thing, and I think that trend will switch round soon. IMPERIAL AURA (9/2 fav) ran in a good race at Cheltenham last time. CHAMPAGNE MYSTERY (25/1) can make the frame. SENSULANO has decent form if a miracle let her in and she would also be a bet.

Selections
IMPERIAL AURA @ 5/1 general, bigger on the day, I’d imagine.
CHAMPAGNE MYSTERY @ 33/1 with Ladbrokes. At least 5 places recommended.




NATIONAL HUNT CHALLENGE CUP
AMATEUR RIDERS’ NOVICES’ CHASE
3 Miles 5 Furlongs 201 Yards, Grade 2 Novice Chase


Overview
Its now 9 renewals since the quality of runners started improving. No more plodders! Last year, two horses managed to get round without incident, but they’ve now chopped of 2 furlongs off the distance.


Last 10 Winners- average 4.5 stars
2019  ****    Le Breuil (14/1)
2018  ****    Rathvinden (9/2)
2017  *****  Tiger Roll (16/1)
2016  *****  Minella Rocco (8/1)
2015  ****    Cause Of Causes (8/1)
2014  ***      Midnight Prayer (8/1)
2013  *****  Back In Focus (9/4 fav)
2012  *****  Teaforthree (5/1 fav)
2011  *****  Chicago Grey (5/1 fav)
2010  *****  Poker De Sivola (14/1)


10-Year Trends
10/10 Had raced over fences at least 3 times.
10/10 Had finished in the top 5 last time.
10/10 Had finished in the top 2 in a Chase over at least 2 miles 71/2 furlongs. [Le Breuil was 3rd]
  9/10 Had achieved a hurdles rating of 133 or more in their career. [Midnight Prayer 121 in 2014]
  9/10 Had raced in a Graded Chase. [Exception: Midnight Prayer won a Class 3 Chase]
  9/10 Had an Adjusted RPR of 154+. [The last 9. 7 of those were 159+] [OR 139+]
  9/10 Were rated within 9lbs of the RPR Top Rated horse. [Midnight Prayer 12lbs]
  8/10 Had won over at least 3 miles in any sphere. [Exceptions were placed only]
  8/10 Were aged between 6 and 8 years old. [Exceptions 9 & 10]
  8/10 Had been off the track for between 24 and 78 days. [Exceptions 18 & 134 days]
  8/10 Had finished in the top 2 in one of their last 2 starts. [Exceptions DNF & 5th]


Waiting on the sidelines at this extreme trip is a Sire stat:
10/10 Were by a Sire who's stamina index was 11.5 furlongs or more. (Or Dam’s Sire if no rating.)


Additionally
The last 19 winners had at least 3 starts over fences.
19 of the last 20 winners has run between 4 and 8 times that season.
20 of the last 22 winners had finished in the top 4 in their last 2 starts.
19 of the last 21 winners had finished in the top 2 in a 3 mile Chase.
11 of the last 18 winners had finished in the top 2 last time.
Since 1989, only two 6 year olds had won the race (2009 and 2016)


Ages (Wins-Places-Runners)
  5yo  0-0-1
  6yo  1-3-19
  7yo  4-10-77
  8yo  3-5-50
  9yo  1-1-18
10yo  1-1-7
12yo  0-0-1


Trainers (Wins-Places-Runners)
Gordon Elliott (Ire) 3-0-8
Willie Mullins (Ire) 2-3-14
Colin Tizzard 0-2-2
Nigel Twiston-Davies 0-1-9


Contenders
*          Anteros (100/1)
This 12 year old fails plenty of trends.

*****  Carefully Selected (7/4 fav)
Perfection. Bred to stay. Very short in the market. Has 3 runs, I’d actually prefer more.

**        Clondaw Cian (66/1)
4th last year, or last of 4 as I’d prefer it. Benn not winnig lots of chases since.

****    Forza Milan (8/1)
Ticks lots of boxes, but still a maiden and has plenty to find with the top rated pair. Top amateur on board.

**        Lamanver Pippin (16/1)
Was an average hurdler and hasn’t done too much over fences. Just the 2 starts too and off for 4 months. All negative to his chances in this.

*****  Lord Du Mesnil (7/1)
Been running in some top staying handicaps out of novice company, including 3rd in the Grand National trial at Haydock. On the shortlist.

*****  Newtide (9/1)
Just 2 starts (won both) makes him a risky proposition. Passes all the other trends.

**        Ocean Cove (50/1)
Another with just the 2 runs over fences. No graded form means he’s had little chance to improve his rating, so can’t be recommended here.

****    Ravenhill (11/2)
Jamie Codd on board shaves a few points off his price. Yet to run in a Graded Chase, like so many recent winners, he’s also been off for ages on the back of a fall last time out. He’s 10, though Rathvinden, 2 years ago, was also 10.

***      Redzor (50/1)
Needs to improve to feature here.


***      Smoking Gun (25/1)
9th in the Thyestes at Gowran Park in January is ok. Beat Early Doors before that and has a chance.


*          Some Can Dance (100/1)
Clearly not good enough on what he’s shown so far.

***      Springfield Fox (15/2)
Ran just 18 days ago. 2 starts and 2 wins. More needed here and is passed over.

****    The Hollow Ginge (25/1)
Much better terms with Lord Du Mesnil today. Outside chance.




Contenders
The favourite, Carefully Selected is short enough in the market. LORD DU MESNIL is preferred with experience in open staying handicaps a big positive. Smoking Gun, the best of the outsiders.

 
Selection
LORD DU MESNIL @ 7/1 general. Possibly bigger on the day.

No comments: